Because of that, Hampton coach Mike Smith planned to start Gunter but use Hagans, also a starting receiver, on occasion behind center.
Which is what Smith did in the Crabbers' first game, an overtime loss to Heritage. Hagans played better than Gunter that day, so the coach made a change the next week. With Hagans starting at quarterback, Hampton won the rest of its games and captured the state championship.
"I had to make the move," Smith said. "The reason he didn't start at first was the other kid had been around and deserved a chance. But it was pretty clear that Marques was the best quarterback on our team."
That situation bears some similarities to the current one at Virginia, where Hagans is a redshirt freshman. He began the season as junior Matt Schaub's backup, but he outplayed Schaub in last week's opening loss to Colorado State.
Now the question UVa coach Al Groh needs to answer is: Is Hagans the best quarterback on the team?
The answer probably isn't as clear to Groh as it was to Smith – and for good reason. For one thing, it's difficult to judge either quarterback after one game. Hagans remains inexperienced and unproven. Schaub has size and obvious potential as a passer. Each brings a different set of skills to the position.
Also, no one expects a fairy-tale ending, with Hagans starting the rest of the season and leading the Cavaliers to the national championship.
The only real parallel to his high school situation, in Hagans' mind, is his own attitude.
"I just try to always stay ready and have confidence in myself," he said. "Then if I get a chance, I try to make the most of it."
Hagans has a history of doing just that. At Hampton, he won 22 straight games as the starting quarterback. Still, because of his 5-foot-10 stature and 4.5 speed in the 40-yard dash, most colleges recruited him as a defensive back.
He was set to go to Georgia as a cornerback before the entire coaching staff was fired the day after his official visit. He ended up signing with Indiana as a quarterback, but low SAT scores forced him to enroll at Fork Union Military Academy.
At FUMA, he quickly endeared himself to coach John Shuman, who calls Hagans "one of my favorite guys." In one year, he threw for nearly 2,000 yards and ran for 900 more.
"The kid has a lot of heart," Shuman said. "When it was time to battle with the [Division] I-A guys, we'd have two or three guys shrink back, and two or three guys who would emerge. He'd battle the big boys every time. He's a leader."
Hagans also caught the attention of Groh, who lost recruiting battles for several other highly-regarded passers. Hagans ended up being the only quarterback in Groh's first class, though the coach worked almost exclusively with tall, dropback passers in the NFL.
"The first thing I heard is that he won a lot of games," Groh said. "You don't have to be a very smart coach, which I'm often not, to put a tape in."
Groh clearly likes the athletic ability Hagans brings to the position. Hagans offers a sharper contrast to Schaub than Bryson Spinner did last year. Hagans ran 11 times against Colorado State, more than Spinner did in any single game.
"The player last year was a good runner," Groh said. "This is one of the fastest players on the team."
Hagans completed 10 of 13 passes for 120 yards against the Rams, though most of those were short throws to running backs and tight ends. His arm remains a question mark. Still, Smith insists that Hagans is a better passer than former college standouts of similar size, including Georgia Tech's Joe Hamilton, Virginia Tech's Michael Vick and Clemson's Woody Dantzler.
"He's going to be a great college quarterback," Smith said. "He's special. Don't get me wrong. I think Schaub is a good quarterback, too, but Marques will be a great one. He does everything so well."
Florida State coach Bobby Bowden said Hagans appears to have similar skills to Iowa State senior Seneca Wallace, who threw for 313 yards against the Seminoles in a 38-31 loss last week.
Wallace "is way ahead in maturity," Bowden said. "But this kid's ability is probably going to match him as he comes up. He looked good last week, I know that."
Hagans wasn't perfect. He slightly overthrew open receiver Billy McMullen on a deep pass. He also fumbled on Virginia's final offensive play.
After leading the Cavaliers from their own 18-yard line to the Colorado State 3, he sprinted to his right and tried to run it in. Knowing there wouldn't be time for another play if he was tackled, he attempted what Groh called "a bounce pass" into the end zone, hoping his team would recover the fumble. It didn't work.
"That was a mistake," Hagans said. "Sometimes you've got to learn the hard way. I'd love to have it back, but I've got to move forward."
Groh has declined to say who will start against the fifth-ranked Seminoles on Saturday, but he has strongly implied that both quarterbacks will see action.
Because of that, Hagans said, starting "isn't important. It's important that when my coach puts me in, I make the most of my opportunity."
